How To Choose: Hiking Boots vs Hiking Shoes vs Trail Runners

Hiking boots, hiking shoes and trail running shoes are all popular choices for exploring New Zealand's tracks, trails and backcountry, but they're designed with different adventures in mind. While hiking boots and shoes prioritise support, protection and durability, trail running shoes focus on comfort, agility and low weight.

So, which is right for you?

In this guide, we'll break down the key differences between all three, including where each performs best, their strengths and trade-offs, and how to choose the right hiking footwear for your next adventure. Whether you're planning a local day walk, a Great Walk, or a multi-day tramp, the best option will come down to where you're going, what you're carrying, and the conditions underfoot.

Why Choose Hiking Boots?

The Maximum Support Option

For decades, hiking boots have been the go-to footwear choice for trampers and hikers headed into the bush. They’re designed for support, protection, and stability, and shine in rough conditions, on uneven terrain, and on adventures that don’t seem to have an end.

Key Features

While modern hiking boots come in a variety of styles, there’s a few core characteristics that set them apart from other footwear options:

Mid or Highcut Design – Most hiking boots extend above the ankle and provide extra support and protection to your ankles while you’re traversing uneven terrain. Higher cuts are also great for keeping out the dirt, scree, and other pieces of the world you’d rather not bring home with you.

Stiff Midsole – Compared to trail running shoes, hiking boots typically have stiffer sole construction. This improves the stability and support underfoot, especially when you’re carrying a heavy pack or walking on rocky riverbeds.

Protection – Many hiking boots include reinforced toe caps, tough uppers and more substantial cushioning. These features work together to keep your feet comfortable over long tramps, as well as offer protection from roots, rocks, and other track hazards you might find yourself up against.

Weather Resistance – The entire hiking footwear family (including boots!) use waterproof membranes of varying types to keep your feet dry, making them a solid choice for wet tracks, long grass, muddy conditions, and cold weather. Many popular brands often include a little fabric tag or badge to indicate that they’re amphibious, and it’s worth the investment — you’ll otherwise be left with the hope that your hut has a good fireplace for overnight drying!

Adventures where Hiking Boots are Best

There’s plenty of situations where hiking boots have a clear advantage. If the terrain’s a bit trickier, weather’s looking a bit dicey, and your pack starts to weigh a bit more, then they could be the pick for you.

Here’s where hiking boots perform best:

Multi-day tramps where you're carrying camping gear, food and extra clothing
Alpine and backcountry adventures where conditions can change quickly
Rocky, technical or uneven terrain that demands more stability underfoot
Wet, muddy and colder conditions where additional protection is welcome
Long-term durability, especially for hikers who spend plenty of time outdoors

While they’re not always the lightest option, the added support, protection, and durability can be worth it if the conditions demand it.

Check out our large range of Men’s hiking boots and Women’s hiking boots to get sorted for your next big adventure.

SHOP

Scarpa Unisex Terra GTX Hiking Boots

NZ$549.99 Members NZ$494.99

Hi-Tec Men's Tarantula Mid WP Hiking Boots

NZ$199.99 NZ$99.00 Now NZ$74.00

Hi-Tec Women's Tarantula WP Mid Hiking Shoes

NZ$199.99 NZ$119.00 Now NZ$89.00

Why Choose Hiking Shoes?

The Best of Both Worlds

Sitting somewhere between hiking boots and trail running shoes, hiking shoes combine many of the protective features of a traditional boot with the lighter, more agile feel of trail runners. For many hikers, they're the best of both worlds.

If you're not carrying a particularly heavy pack or venturing into demanding alpine terrain, hiking shoes are a versatile option for everything from local day walks to overnight tramps.

Key Features

Like hiking boots, hiking shoes are built with support, durability and protection in mind. The main difference is their lower-cut design, which reduces weight and allows for greater freedom of movement around the ankle.

Low-Cut Design – Unlike hiking boots, hiking shoes sit below the ankle. This creates a lighter, more flexible feel while still offering more structure and support than most trail running shoes. The lower profile can also feel cooler and more comfortable in warmer conditions, while making it easier to move naturally over varied terrain.

Supportive Construction – Many hiking shoes use similar midsole technology to hiking boots, providing a stable platform underfoot for long days on the trail. While they don't typically offer the same level of ankle support as a boot, they often provide more stability and protection than trail running shoes.

Durable Materials – Hiking shoes are designed to withstand regular use on rough tracks and uneven terrain. Many feature reinforced toe caps, durable uppers and protective overlays that help defend against rocks, roots and general trail wear and tear.

Waterproof Options Available – Just like hiking boots, many hiking shoes are available with waterproof membranes, making them a great option for damp tracks, muddy conditions and New Zealand's famously changeable weather.

Adventures where Hiking Shoes are Best

For many people, hiking shoes hit the sweet spot. They offer more support and durability than trail running shoes, while remaining lighter and more agile than traditional hiking boots. If you're unsure where you sit in the hiking boots vs trail running shoes debate, hiking shoes are often a great place to start.

Here’s where hiking shoes perform best:

Day trips where you're carrying a normal amount of gear, food and extra clothing
Backcountry adventures where conditions can change quickly
Rocky, technical or uneven terrain that demands more stability underfoot
Wet and cold conditions where protection is welcome
Long-term durability, especially for hikers who spend plenty of time outdoors.

Explore our range of Men’s hiking shoes and Women’s hiking shoes to get kitted out for your next multi-day or day hike.

SHOP

Merrell Women's Moab 3 GTX WP Hiking Shoes

NZ$349.00 Members NZ$314.10

Merrell Men's Moab 3 GTX WP Hiking Shoes

NZ$349.00 Members NZ$314.10

Merrell Women's Moab 3 GTX WP Hiking Shoes

NZ$349.00 Members NZ$314.10

Why Choose Trail Running Shoes?

Light and Fast

Trail runners, or Trail running shoes, shine on fast-paced adventures in off-road terrain. While they’re built for off-road running, some hikers and trampers also use them as a lighter, more comfortable alternative to traditional hiking boots.

Key Features

Compared to hiking boots, most trail running footwear prioritise agility and efficiency over maximum support and protection. This means they’re ideal for easy to mid-level day hikes, well-formed tracks, and fast, light adventuring. Here’s the rundown:

Lightweight Construction – Perhaps the biggest difference between trail running shoes and hiking boots is weight. Trail running shoes use significantly lighter materials and a lower cut design, which helps to reduce fatigue when you’re spending a full day out on the track.

Flexible Feel – Unlike the stiffer construction of many hiking boots, trail running shoes are designed to flex with your foot. Also, trail running footwear requires little to no break-in period, so you don’t have to battle through blisters on your first adventure.

Breathable Upper Materials – Lightweight mesh uppers are used in the construction of trail shoes to maximise airflow and improve breathability. While they generally offer less protection from wet weather than waterproof hiking boots, they dry much faster after rain, stream crossings or muddy sections of track.

Excellent Tread – Despite their lightweight design, trail running shoes can offer impressive traction. As they’re designed for faster adventuring that their hiking boot counterparts, it’s natural that your foot-to-track placement may be less thought out. To balance this, trail running shoes feature aggressive outsoles designed to grip dirt, gravel, mud, and rocky terrain, keeping you upright at speed on both flats and inclines!

Adventures where Trail Running Shoes are Best

Trail running shoes excel when comfort, efficiency and low weight are the priority and you’re heading into low-medium impact terrain. They’re of course a great fit for any trail runner, and for hikers who prioritise comfort, speed, and lighter weights over the stability and protection offered by hiking boots.

They're a great choice for:

Trail runs (although that probably goes without saying!)
Day hikes and weekend adventures on established tracks
Fastpacking trips where covering distance efficiently is the goal
Great Walk-style trails and well-maintained routes
Warm-weather hiking where breathability matters
Lightweight gear setups with minimal pack weight

That said, trail running shoes aren't necessarily the best choice for every adventure. If you're carrying a heavy overnight pack, travelling through rugged alpine terrain or expecting cold and consistently wet conditions, you may prefer the extra support, protection and durability offered by hiking boots. The right choice ultimately comes down to where you're hiking, what you're carrying and the kind of experience you're after on the track.

Shop our large range of Men’s trail running shoes and Women’s trail running shoes to get sorted for your next big adventure.

SHOP

Salomon Women's XA PRO 3D V9 Running Shoes

NZ$289.99 Members NZ$260.99

Salomon Men's XA PRO 3D V9 Running Shoes

NZ$289.99 Members NZ$260.99

Salomon Women's Speedcross 6 Running Shoes

NZ$289.99 Members NZ$260.99

Hiking Boots vs Hiking Shoes vs Trail Running Shoes?

When it comes to hiking boots vs trail running shoes, there’s not clear winner. They’re both designed for time spent on the trail, but they shine in different conditions.

Hiking boots prioritise support, protection and durability. They're built to handle rough terrain, heavier pack loads and challenging weather. Trail running shoes, on the other hand, focus on comfort, agility and low weight, making them a popular choice for day hikes and fast-moving adventures.

Ultimately, the best hiking footwear is the one that matches the adventure. Whether you prefer the support of hiking boots or the lightweight comfort of trail running shoes, choosing the right option for the conditions will help you get the most out of your time outdoors. For many outdoor enthusiasts, the answer isn't one or the other. It's having the right tool for the adventure ahead.

FAQs

Are trail running shoes good for hiking?

Yes, trail running shoes can be a great option for hiking, depending on where you're heading and what you're carrying. Their lightweight design, comfortable fit and responsive feel make them popular for day hikes, well-maintained tracks and fast-and-light adventures.

That said, trail runners generally offer less support and protection than hiking boots. If you're carrying a heavy pack, tackling technical terrain or heading into alpine environments, you may prefer the added stability of a hiking boot.

Are hiking boots better than trail running shoes?

Not necessarily. When comparing hiking boots vs trail running shoes, there isn't a clear winner.

Hiking boots typically provide more support, protection and durability, making them well suited to rough terrain, multi-day hikes and challenging conditions. Trail runners are lighter, more flexible and often more comfortable straight out of the box, which can make them a great choice for longer distances and everyday hiking.

The best option depends on the terrain, weather, pack weight and your personal preference.

Do I need extra ankle support for hiking?

Not every hiker needs extra ankle support. While hiking boots often feature a higher cut around the ankle, research and real-world experience suggest that strong footing, fitness and confidence on uneven terrain can be just as important.

Many hikers comfortably complete everything from day walks to multi-day tramps in trail running shoes. However, if you're carrying a heavier pack, recovering from an injury or regularly hiking on rough terrain, you may appreciate the additional support and protection offered by hiking boots.

Are waterproof hiking boots worth it?

For many hikers, yes. Waterproof hiking boots can help keep your feet drier and more comfortable in wet weather, muddy conditions and colder environments. They're often a popular choice for multi-day tramping trips where consistent rain, snow or saturated tracks are a possibility. The trade-off is that waterproof footwear can sometimes feel warmer in hot weather and may take longer to dry if water gets in from the top.

If you regularly hike in New Zealand's changeable conditions, waterproof hiking boots are often worth considering.

How long do trail running shoes last compared to hiking boots?

In general, hiking boots tend to last longer than trail running shoes due to their more robust construction. The lifespan of either option depends on how often you hike, the terrain you cover and how well you look after your footwear. Many trail runners will show signs of wear sooner because they're designed to prioritise low weight and flexibility, while hiking boots are built with durability in mind.

Rather than focusing solely on age, it's a good idea to replace your footwear when the tread wears down, cushioning breaks down or the upper begins to lose its structural integrity.